It’s fair to say we didn’t have a single poor meal on Maui. From fresh-caught seafood to locally sourced ingredients bursting with island flavor, finding your favorite eats on Maui is an experience all its own. With so many incredible restaurants across the island, it’s impossible to cover them all—but these standout meals are the ones we’re still talking about long after the trip ended. For more on the island’s adventures, check out our posts on the Lahaina Historic Trail, snorkeling in Molokini, and the Royal Lahaina Luau to plan a full Maui itinerary.
This post may contain affiliate links, meaning if you purchase something through one of these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you! Read the full disclosure policy here.
Table of Contents
Eat at the Legendary Mama’s Fish House: A Beachfront Paradise on Maui’s Shores
A friend stated that this was one of the best restaurants in Hawaii. I made reservations about 2 weeks in advance. With a reputation that spans decades, this restaurant has earned its place as a beloved culinary institution. Mama’s Fish House has been delighting diners since 1973, and its reputation for serving the finest seafood in Hawaii is well-deserved. Locals and visitors alike are drawn to its timeless charm, exceptional service, and commitment to sourcing the freshest catch of the day. It definitely ranks high among our favorite eats on Maui.
First, the path to the restaurant was stunning! With open-air seating, the lit beach torches and the beach are amazing. Although expensive, it is worth it for the setting alone. For our appetizer, we shared the macadamia nut crab cake and the venison with honey-citrus. Each plate is a masterpiece, showcasing the chef’s creativity and passion for culinary artistry. The mahi-mahi I ate was filled with crab and lobster and topped with macadamia nuts. Barry had the Ono Tahitian with Hana lime and taro chips. Words cannot describe these tasty dishes. The Hana Banana Crisp sealed the deal—worth every bite and every penny.
Local Fair at the Lahaina Fish Company: A Gastronomic Journey through Lahaina’s Culinary Heritage
Enjoying a sumptuous meal by the water while listening to the waves creates a night to remember. At the Lahaina Fish Company, you can look forward to enjoying fresh fish that comes straight from local fishermen. Every dish shares a story about the sea and how the community is linked to the ocean. I suggest enjoying a Mai Tai while taking in the beautiful scenery. The dishes mix traditional Hawaiian flavors with influences from Asian, European, and Polynesian cuisines, resulting in a unique taste that is distinctly Lahaina. Another spot not to miss when exploring favorite eats on Maui.
For dinner, I chose the Seafood Lau Lau, which is a mix of mahi-mahi, scallops, and shrimp served on a bed of spinach and brown rice. The meal was new, tasty, and served in a nice bento box. My husband ordered the Island Fish Coconut Curry. He really enjoyed it! I don’t really like the curry. The delicious mana pie was the ideal way to finish our meal—truly among the favorite eats on Maui.
Kimo’s: A Timeless Lahaina Tradition for Exquisite Dining
The perfect spot for spending the Aloha Hour. Perched right on the water’s edge, Kimo’s boasts panoramic views of the Pacific Ocean and the neighboring islands. It’s a very relaxing environment for listening to local entertainment. As day turns to dusk, Kimo’s becomes a haven for witnessing breathtaking sunsets. I had an excellent piece of ono. The fish sauteed perfectly. Barry had the fish tacos. The flavor was so fresh and savory. If you go to Kimo’s, you MUST try their famous Hula Pie! We shared the decadent dessert, drizzled with chocolate sauce and macadamia nuts, served on their signature plate. Kimo’s is more than just a restaurant—it is a part of Lahaina’s storied past, making it a must-visit when looking for favorite eats on Maui. Since its establishment in 1977, Kimo’s has welcomed generations of guests, leaving an indelible mark on Maui’s culinary landscape.
Leilani’s On The Beach: An Oceanfront Haven for Unforgettable Dining
Leilani’s On The Beach in Whalers Village has an outstanding sunset view of Molokai’i and Lanai at sunset. It was only a short walk from our Ka’anapali Beach Hotel. The menu at Leilani’s showcases the best of Hawaii’s culinary treasures, featuring fresh catches from the sea, locally sourced produce, and traditional island favorites. Each dish is a reflection of the rich flavors and cultural diversity of the Hawaiian Islands. The macadamia nut crusted mahi-mahi was absolutely incredible! If you go to Leilani’s, you MUST try their Hula Pie! I won’t say which pie I liked best between Kimo’s and Leilani’s. Both were delicious. The warm and attentive staff makes you feel like part of the Ohana (family), truly adding to the feeling of discovering the favorite eats on Maui.
More Favorite Eats & Drinks Across Maui
While our highlights showcase some of Maui’s most iconic dining spots, the island offers countless other culinary adventures. From casual beachside shacks serving fresh fish tacos to farm-to-table restaurants in lush upcountry settings, there’s something for every palate.
For wine lovers, a visit to Tedeschi Winery, now known as MauiWine in Upcountry Maui, is a must. Known for its small-batch wines crafted from locally grown grapes, the winery offers tastings and stunning vineyard views—a perfect way to experience Maui beyond the oceanfront. Other local favorites include food trucks in Kihei, traditional Hawaiian plate lunches, and unique cafés in Paia and Makawao, where island flavors meet creativity.
Exploring these spots allows you to taste the diverse flavors of Maui while enjoying the scenery, culture, and aloha spirit that make the island so unforgettable.
What to Bring When Dining in Maui
Dining on Maui is usually a relaxed, island-style experience, but a few items can make your meals even more enjoyable. Bring light, breathable clothing for comfort in open-air or beachfront restaurants, a hat and sunglasses for sunny terraces, and reef-safe sunscreen if you plan to enjoy sunset views outdoors. A light jacket or wrap is handy for cooler evenings or breezy spots by the ocean. Don’t forget a camera or smartphone to capture the stunning ocean views and colorful dishes—some meals are as beautiful as they are delicious.
Final Thoughts: Savoring Maui’s Culinary Treasures
Our meals on Maui were more than food. They were experiences that brought the island’s culture, flavors, and aloha spirit to life. From the legendary Mama’s Fish House to sunset dinners at Leilani’s On The Beach, every bite told a story of fresh ingredients and tradition. Whether you’re a foodie or just craving island flavors, Maui offers an unforgettable culinary journey.
What’s your favorite Maui dining memory? Share your must-visit restaurants in the comments below!
